Pizza In Pinehurst NC: Your Ultimate Guide To Savoring The Best Slices!

Author Mary J. Goldsberry 14 Apr 2025

When it comes to pizza in Pinehurst NC, you're about to uncover a world of cheesy, saucy, and downright delicious options that'll leave your taste buds dancing like they're at a pizza party! Whether you're a local craving that perfect slice or a visitor ready to explore the town's culinary scene, this guide has got you covered. From wood-fired masterpieces to classic NY-style pies, we're diving deep into why Pinehurst is becoming a pizza paradise.

Pinehurst NC might be known for its golf courses and serene landscapes, but let me tell ya, the pizza game here is on fire. This quaint Southern town has been leveling up its food scene, and pizza is at the forefront of this delicious revolution. So grab a napkin, because we're about to dish out all the details you need to know before your next pizza adventure.

But hey, it's not just about grabbing a slice—it's about experiencing the culture, the flavors, and the stories behind each pizzeria. From family-owned joints to upscale dining spots, Pinehurst offers something for everyone. Let's dive right in and discover why pizza in Pinehurst NC is worth talking about!

Why Pinehurst NC is a Must-Visit for Pizza Lovers

Let's face it, folks—Pinehurst might not be the first place that comes to mind when you think pizza, but trust me, it deserves a spot on your foodie bucket list. The town has been quietly building a reputation as a pizza hotspot, blending Southern charm with Italian traditions to create some seriously unforgettable pies. And guess what? It's not just about the pizza—it's about the entire dining experience!

What makes Pinehurst stand out? For starters, the town's diverse culinary scene means you can find everything from classic Margherita to gourmet creations topped with local ingredients. Plus, many of these pizzerias take pride in using fresh, high-quality ingredients that reflect the region's agricultural roots. It's like getting the best of both worlds—authentic Italian flair with a Southern twist!

And let's not forget the vibe. Whether you're dining al fresco on a sunny afternoon or cozying up inside during a chilly evening, Pinehurst's pizzerias offer an ambiance that's as inviting as the food itself. It's no wonder locals and visitors alike are falling head over heels for pizza in Pinehurst NC!

Top Pizza Joints in Pinehurst NC

Now that we've got your appetite revved up, let's talk about the cream of the crop when it comes to pizza in Pinehurst NC. These are the spots where the crust is always perfect, the sauce is always on point, and the cheese is always melty. Trust me, you don't want to miss out on these gems!

1. Amici's Pizzeria

Amici's is the talk of the town when it comes to wood-fired pizza. Their crust is crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and perfectly seasoned. But what really sets them apart is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients. From their signature Margherita to their gourmet creations like the BBQ Chicken Pizza, there's something for everyone here.

2. Bella's Italian Kitchen

Bella's is all about bringing a taste of Italy to Pinehurst. Their pizzas are made with love and attention to detail, featuring homemade marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella. If you're feeling adventurous, try their Four Cheese Pizza—it's a game-changer!

3. The Village Tavern

This cozy spot is perfect for a casual night out with friends or family. Their pizza options range from classic favorites to creative combinations, and they even offer gluten-free crusts for those with dietary restrictions. Plus, their beer selection is top-notch, making it the ideal spot for a pizza and pint night!

Understanding the Different Types of Pizza in Pinehurst NC

Pizza is a versatile dish, and Pinehurst NC embraces that diversity wholeheartedly. Whether you're a fan of thin-crust, deep-dish, or something in between, you'll find it all here. Let's break it down:

Wood-Fired Pizza

Wood-fired pizza is all the rage in Pinehurst, and for good reason. The high heat of the wood-fired ovens gives the crust that perfect char, while the intense heat locks in the flavors of the toppings. It's like magic in a pie!

NY-Style Pizza

For those who crave a slice they can fold and eat on the go, NY-style pizza is the way to go. Pinehurst has a few spots that specialize in this classic style, offering large, foldable slices that are perfect for sharing—or not sharing, depending on your mood!

Gourmet Pizza

If you're looking to elevate your pizza game, Pinehurst's gourmet pizzerias have got you covered. From truffle oil to arugula, these toppings take your pizza experience to the next level. It's like dining at a five-star restaurant, but with pizza!

How to Choose the Best Pizza for You

With so many options available, choosing the perfect pizza can feel overwhelming. But don't worry—we've got some tips to help you make the right choice:

Know Your Toppings: Are you a meat lover, veggie enthusiast, or cheese aficionado? Knowing your preferences can help you narrow down your choices.
Consider the Crust: Thin, thick, or gluten-free? The crust is just as important as the toppings, so choose wisely!
Think About Atmosphere: Do you want a casual slice-and-go spot or a sit-down dining experience? Pinehurst has options for both!

Healthier Pizza Options in Pinehurst NC

Let's be real—pizza isn't exactly known for being the healthiest food out there. But Pinehurst's pizzerias are stepping up to the plate by offering healthier alternatives. From whole-grain crusts to veggie-packed toppings, you can enjoy your pizza guilt-free. And let's not forget the gluten-free options, which are perfect for those with dietary restrictions.

Gluten-Free Pizza

Many pizzerias in Pinehurst now offer gluten-free crusts, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice of the action. These crusts are made with alternative flours and are just as delicious as their gluten-filled counterparts. So if you're avoiding gluten, don't worry—you won't miss out!

Veggie-Packed Pizzas

For those looking to add more veggies to their diet, Pinehurst's pizzerias have got you covered. From roasted bell peppers to fresh spinach, these toppings are not only delicious but also packed with nutrients. It's like having your cake and eating it too—well, pizza, that is!

Pizza Delivery and Takeout in Pinehurst NC

Not in the mood to dine out? No problem! Pinehurst's pizzerias offer excellent delivery and takeout options, so you can enjoy your favorite slices from the comfort of your own home. Plus, with the town's mild climate, outdoor dining is always an option if you're looking to enjoy your pizza al fresco.

Popular Delivery Services

While Pinehurst might not have the big-name delivery apps you're used to, many local pizzerias offer their own delivery services. Some even partner with local drivers to ensure your pizza arrives hot and fresh. And let's be honest, nothing beats supporting local businesses!

Tips for Hosting a Pizza Party in Pinehurst NC

Planning a pizza party? Pinehurst NC has everything you need to make it a success. From ordering from multiple pizzerias to creating a DIY pizza bar, the possibilities are endless. Here are a few tips to get you started:

Order from Multiple Places: Why stick to one pizzeria when you can try them all? Ordering from multiple spots ensures everyone gets their favorite slice.
Create a DIY Bar: Let your guests get creative with a DIY pizza bar featuring various toppings and sauces. It's a fun way to keep everyone entertained!
Don't Forget the Drinks: Whether it's beer, wine, or soda, make sure you have plenty of drinks on hand to pair with your pizza.

Conclusion: Your Pizza Adventure Awaits!

So there you have it, folks—everything you need to know about pizza in Pinehurst NC. From wood-fired masterpieces to gourmet creations, this town has something for every pizza lover. Whether you're dining out, ordering in, or hosting a pizza party, Pinehurst offers an unforgettable pizza experience.

Now it's your turn to take action! Head out and explore the town's pizzerias, share your favorite slices with friends, and don't forget to leave a review or two. And if you're hungry for more, check out our other articles on all things food and travel in Pinehurst NC. Happy pizza hunting!